Natural born dictators
I and my father were sitting watching the news on tv. Drinking sweet tee. Like usual Syrians.
Both with our own mountains of anger, unjustice feelings, and bitterness in this poor rotten place to live, crushing our chests. Allthough my experiences are nothing to compare to his.. Watching the arab news does'nt really help the mood ofcourse.
I said bitterly: I wish I could remove the filthy [part of] memory of us young arabs. Let us get reborn like humans this time and have a different future than this pitch black present!
[ removing all these dark age thoughts making us to be proud of (!)living like pre-viruses million years ago, and that, in the name of relgion and traditions(!), and having violent traditions, etc etc]
He answered me something about it won't be enough. I need to do that with their parents too or otherwise they will turn them back to what they where.
But let's just stop my black bitterness a while , we all know we got problems. Really bad. Just like so many Syrians, I was bitter, felt very alienated in my own city, there was no hope here. No future. And I felt there is nothing that holds me back here..I could'nt care any more. When I calmed down I realized how things just get worse when young pepole loose their mood and moral like this, it is so dangerous not to care any more..Since we are living dead like this. As we have been, for many years...I was wondering : How and why did we end up like this??
Let's start with the begging: We learn to obey our parents to any price and respect them deeply. As we should, belonging to good conservative respectfull families. It means: Do not ever dare to disscus with them, when they give you orders, they are always right even when they are wrong. Learn to blindly obey them and cancell your [disrespectful] opinion and independet thinking. You are not permitted to use your dangerous mind yet. You are younger and smaller so you are weaker and your words worth almost nothing. And you, the smaller weaker, will be beaten up by the bigger.
Same goes for teachers when you go to school. And they also can beat you a lot and it doesn't even matter if it was your fault or not. If you try to explain that means you dared to discuss, you unrespectful, and you get twice as much beaten and humulated in front of all your freinds. And don't you dare be disrespectful and look UP in the eyes of the teacher, as if you are daring to show her anger or protest you animal, you keep your eyes and head DOWN..[where you belong]. And you might be spared on teacher's day if you bring good gifts!
Back at home : Yoy are helpfull and respektfull to your parents, your mother is a good wife who takes care of your father, respects him and obeys him. Oh and by the way in Syria thank god women live like queens and suffer no discrimination compared with men, and everyone in the family is drowning with love and care. Your stressed mother forgot the required amount respect in her looks to her loving mother in law, then your bigger wiser father reminded your weaker crying mother about respect. And you ran away out of respect for your father's angry red eyes. Your wise parents allready know what you should study/ do when you are older. They know best.
In the school you learn to respect and love your country and leader It means your leader, and learn every word he ever said, and remember he is eternal...and you can look UP to his pictures and statues covering the city from DOWN where you belong. And you sure as hell learn to respect him, he seems more loved and powerfull than god.
Beeing youngster, You learn to stay at your room,you are allowed to study, obey your parents, do not meet with devil (other sex).They know best who you should marry and the rest of YOUR life with, And if you are a girl,( living like a queen here thank god), do remember your loving parents might kill every atom in your body and get away with it..They know best who you should marry..And even take honour in it!So Respect and obey!
I know I might have exaggerated a bit, but not that much...Now...With this impossible weight of attempts to deny your rights, deny your right of independant existence, attempt to fight nature, you get used to this sort of life. You can't wait untill you get your hands on some one weaker than you, so you can finally have some power! There is a power and control absolut hysteria!! and generations inherit it as it goes on.
And so...Our great proude, eastern conservative socities , are so true ( Asileh) and great. And with this great healthy tradition of hearing and accepting the other opinion,and Respect, thank god no human rights are horribly violated in Tadmur, mazeh, seidnaya, ..No officals are using their power to steal from and oppress the pepole, no neighbours are stealing electricity and phone line from others, no pepole are throwing their garbaga at the common streets or neighbours' garden, no strong rich pepolr are playing with the cheap lives of poor,and the situation here has nothing to do with the law of jungle were the stongest rules...etc.
I don't beleive any one is born a killer, or a dictator...but with the "right" attitude, and in the name of (!!!!!) the holy unbreakable traditions and religion...We can raise a whole country.
I sound quite pessimistic...I admit that. Not all the pepole are like that, but I feel really there are too many...And I think I have the right to explode, some times.
And if there is any foreginer reading here : I meant what I wrote hear, but don't make a jugment too soon though... Syria has a bit of everything..

12 Comments:
hey catherine, i like your blog.
Je crois que tu dois faire attention, ils peuvent savoir ton adresse, et c'est pas difficile du tout. tu dois changer quelque frazes.
Tu pense? Mais j'ai même pas écrit qqc sur ou j'habite..Damas n'est pas pétite. Mais bon, tu as peut-être raison...
Ca ne m'étonnerait pas si qqn intélligent pense que je suis un "danger" pour le pays, et il faut protéger notre pays merde!
Et merci :)
Hey Catherine.
Sorry I insulted you a couple weeks ago. I mis-understood what you were trying to say and for that I apologize.
I'm just guessing here but have you spent much time in France? Educated there possibly?
I enjoy reading from people in places like Syria but I have a very hard time understanding how things got in such a mess.
Are Syrians armed? The civilian population not the military?
The Founding Fathers of the US knew from the begining to NEVER trust the government. That is why they made damn sure there was a Bill of Rights protecting the citizens FROM the government. That is why we are also (US citizens) given a constitutional right to "KEEP AND BEAR ARMS". More for protecting the citizens from the government than from outside forces. We (US) are also explicitly forbidden by the Constitution to deploy the military inside the US borders.
I wish you would read the Bill of Rights, Constitution and the writings of our Founding Fathers, all of which are available on the internet for free, so you will get an idea of who we are and how to form a government that works for those it wishes to govern.
Syria will be no more as it is now at the end of the summer so people like you can effectively rebuild your country starting with a new constitution and government.
Americans don't hate Syrians or any other Muslims, just the assholes running most of the countries. That's who our fight is with, not ordinary people like you.
Unfortunately you will get to see our "REDNECK" side first and you can only make one first impression.
I wish you, Ammar and Karfan all the best of luck in making your country a better place to live.
You are all in my prayers.
May the God of your choice bestow you with the wisdom you will need in the next few short months and also to keep you and your families out of harms way.
great thoughts and blog, keep it up, when i read this post i said, oh, no this is exaggeration, but a mim later, down from my ivory tower.yeah, this is the truth, even it is worst:(
To Bryan, you said "That's who our fight is with, not ordinary people like you."
My question is, why do you fight "them" (the presidents) anyway. What makes it your fight? Why do you have to fight? And what makes you responsible for peoples' fates?
You can say all you want your fight was against Saddam in Iraq, but who are the real casualties? It's the Iraqi civilians, and US soldiers, who were lead to a war for false reasons.
The US doesn't care about freedom or any other nonsense, they care about themselves and that's it, at least with this administration any way. I do not blame the American ppl here, but rather the American administration. So please don't take what I said personally personally.
Catherine, you seem rather a very blunt Syrian girl. You should take pride in that! On the other hand, you might as well tune down some of the tone found in your postings! Don't get me wrong, keep posting; however be careful! on ne sait jamais ce qui se passe dans ce pays, grace a nos mouches a quatre pattes!
Dear Byran,
I read your comment over and over again. It seems to me that you are predicting big changes in Syria in the upcoming months - possibly some shock and awe-. God forbid that happening.
Democrary nor any other idea can be spread by force. History shows that you can't impose any political system by force. Syrians and Arabs are smart enough to improve the situation in their own countries.
The Founding Father of the USA wrote a great constitution and Bill of rights. No one can despute that. But have you ever wondered WHEN these rights were REALLY applied to all Americans??
The formation of the USA was at the expense of the hundreds of Native communities and nations. Even nowdays they live in reserves. I recently read in the National Geography that an Indian Cheif agreed to bury nuclear waste in his land in exchange for some money to build a hospital and few schools for his people- no comment-. The ugly slave trade went on for more than two hundred years. The African Americans were only granted full rights and regonition as equal human beings in the the sixties and seventies. Until now no woman, African American or Native Indian was elected as president of the USA.
Arabs also had their Founding Fathers in the modern era. After the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, elections were held across Bilad al Cham (Syria, Lebanon, Palastine, Jordon), a parliment was elected, a constitution draw. On 8th March 1918 the Arab state was founded. Based in Damascus. It was a democratically elected government with King Faisal as a ceremonial head of state. The finest Arab political figures held ministerial offices. This state represented the dreams, visions and hope of millions of Arabs. Do you know how it ended? The French armies invaded Damascus on 24th July 1918, destoryed the Arab State and put and end to the DEMOCRATICALLY ELECTED government. Arab political figures, members of parliment were prosectuted, many of them sentenced to death in absentee. The British also did their bit and occupied Jordan and Palastine.
The moral is the story is that Syrians and Arabs ARE CAPABLE of building their countries, and realising their dreams without outside help. It is PRECISELY that foreign "help" that on so many occasions hammered real demoracry in the Arab Word and crashed the dreams of million of Arabs.
a corrrection on my earlier comment.
The Arab state lasted from 8 March 1920 to 24 July 1920.
i am the other Amr!!
hi cath, how can i contact you?
would you please contact me?
i like your blog
Hi Catherine,
Wonderful blog! I just found about it. I agree with every word. Yes you sound pessimistic, but this is our base for change!
Good luck...
Catherine,
I agree with you completely about this. First we are trained to respond to our parents on command... then our teachers... then we don't even notice it when the government tries to do the same thing! We are conditioned to believe that those older to us or more established than us are *always* right. It is a lie. It is dangerous.
My situation is unique, I think. My parents immigrated into America and I was raised by them in the typical Syrian manner. However, I attended American public schools all of my life and was thus forced to make a compromise between the two in my worldview. I love my parents, I respect my parents--BUT they, too, have come to respect *me*.
If you ask me, questioning parents and elders is NOT a matter of you being disrespectful. It is a matter of *THEM* being disrespectful if they refuse to allow you an opinion.
I wrote about something similar about a year ago. Check it out if you'd like: http://yamansalahi.net/index.php?page=writings&read=4#post
-- Yaman Salahi
ysalahi@berkeley.edu
Post a Comment
<< Home